| Phil McDougall
Walk into any sporting goods store and you’ll find a rainbow of kettlebells, from a few pounds to “are you serious?” Choosing the right one is the first decision in your kettlebell journey, and getting it wrong is surprisingly common. Pick one that’s too light and you’ll learn bad habits. Pick one that’s too heavy and you’ll get hurt, frustrated or both.
Here’s how I’d choose a first kettlebell, and why one bell won’t be enough for long.

Why “Start Light” Is Only Half Right
Most people are told to start light, and for some exercises that’s good advice. But the kettlebell swing, the foundation of Hardstyle training, is a ballistic hip hinge driven by the biggest muscles in your body. With a bell that’s too light, there’s nothing to load the hips against, so people end up flinging it with their arms. That’s mistake number two in my article on kettlebell swing mistakes.
So the question isn’t just “how strong am I?” It’s “what am I going to do with it?”
The Classic Starting Points
These are the classic Hardstyle starting weights for the swing, assuming you’re healthy and learning with good instruction:
Most women: 8kg (about 18lbs)
Strong or athletic women: 12kg (about 26lbs)
Most men: 16kg (about 35lbs)
Strong or athletic men: 20kg to 24kg (about 44lbs to 53lbs)
“Strong” here means you already lift regularly and can hinge and deadlift with good form. If you’re new to exercise, coming back from injury, older or simply unsure, start at the lighter end and earn the right to go heavier. Your coach can move you up after a session or two. That’s always better than moving you down after a tweak.
Swings vs Presses and Get-Ups
Here’s the part most buyers miss. Ballistic lower-body exercises (swings, cleans, snatches) can handle much heavier bells than slow upper-body “grinds” like the press, the windmill and the Turkish get-up. A 16kg bell that’s perfect for a man’s swing can be far too heavy for his first get-ups.
That’s why most people end up wanting two bells fairly soon:
A lighter bell for get-ups, presses, windmills and goblet squats while you learn them.
A heavier bell for swings and deadlifts.
For example, 8kg and 12kg for many women, or 12kg and 16kg (or 16kg and 24kg) for many men. And honestly, the get-up deserves to be learned with no weight at all first. Balancing a shoe on your fist is a great teacher. I shared a few get-up drills in my Turkish Get Up Hack.

Three Quick Tests Before You Buy
If you can, try a few bells in a gym or store before you commit. Wear flat shoes or go barefoot.
Deadlift it. With the bell between your feet, hinge and stand up ten times. It should feel easy and your back should stay long and neutral. If it doesn’t, it’s too heavy to swing.
Hold it in the rack. Clean it to your chest with both hands and hold it for 30 seconds with your wrist straight and your shoulder down. Your first pressing bell should feel solid here, not shaky.
Press it once, carefully. If you can’t press it overhead with control, it’s not your get-up or pressing bell yet. That’s normal. It may well be your swing bell.
Kilos or Pounds?
Traditional kettlebells come in kilograms, usually in 4kg jumps: 8, 12, 16, 20, 24, 28, 32kg. Old-school lifters still talk in poods, a Russian unit of about 16kg. Many bells sold in the US are labeled in pounds, often in odd-looking numbers like 18, 26, 35 and 53lbs, because they’re rounded versions of the kilogram sizes. If you see 35lbs, think 16kg.
Those 4kg jumps are big, by the way. Going from 16kg to 20kg is a 25% increase in load. Don’t rush them.
What to Look for in a Good Kettlebell
One solid piece. Cast iron or steel, with no seams, sharp edges or burrs on the handle. A rough handle will tear your hands.
A smooth handle that isn’t too thick. You should be able to wrap your fingers around it comfortably, with enough width for two hands for two-hand swings.
A flat, stable base, so it doesn’t roll around when you park it.
A sensible window. Your hand should slide through for the rack and the overhead lock-out without getting jammed.
Simplicity. I’m not a fan of vinyl-coated or adjustable bells for beginners. The handles are often slippery or awkward and the shapes don’t behave like a real kettlebell.
Competition bells are all the same size whatever the weight, which some lifters love because the technique stays identical as you move up. Cast-iron bells grow in size as they get heavier. Either is fine for Hardstyle training. Quality matters far more than style.

When to Move Up
Move up when your current bell feels easy with perfect form, not when you’re bored. A simple marker for the swing: ten crisp swings at the top of every minute for ten minutes, with every rep snappy and every set finished with a strong plank at the top. When that feels comfortable on a couple of sessions in a row, it’s time to think about the next bell.
For the long game, two benchmarks I like (and set as prerequisites before anyone learns the kettlebell snatch):
The Hardstyle swing test: 200 one-arm swings in ten minutes, ten every 30 seconds, with a bell of around a third of your bodyweight.
Walking with a bell of around a quarter of your bodyweight locked out overhead for 45 seconds per arm.
These aren’t beginner targets. They’re signposts that show where the road goes.
A Bell Is Not a Program
The right kettlebell is a great start, but technique is what makes it safe and effective. Kettlebells are easier to get hurt with than most gym equipment, precisely because they ask your whole body to work at speed. Learn the hinge, the swing and the get-up from someone qualified. My Essential Guide to Kettlebells explains the different styles of kettlebell training and what to look for in an instructor, and the Ten Commandments of Kettlebell Training cover the golden rules.
If you’d like me to coach you, have a look at personal training, my workshops and the remote coaching page for current availability. And if your training includes endurance goals too, my sprint triathlon plan for first-timers shows how strength work fits around swimming, cycling and running.
Strength and honor!
Phil McDougall
Keep Reading
